Brian Wilson Reimagines Rhapsody in Blue

August 23, 2010 at 10:12 pm 5 comments

I’ve received numerous emails from friends and colleagues asking my thoughts about the recently released Brian Wilson Reimagines Gershwin CD.  For those of you that haven’t heard anything about this, I direct you to Brian Wilson’s website and the numerous reviews and interviews with Wilson that have appeared.

Taken at face value the disk delivers exactly what we might expect.  It is as if Wilson and his production team took Gershwin’s songs and fed them through the magic Smile machine.  Like that legendary (and only recently completed) album, Wilson’s Gershwin recording opens with an a cappella vocal track–here Rhapsody in Blue.  Additionally, various songs, such as those that comprise the Porgy and Bess medley are connected through instrumental segues, many employing lush strings.  Theremin and harmonica abound, as does the back-beat shuffle of the rhythm section that has become associated with the Beach Boys sound in songs such as “They Can’t Take That Away From Me”and “I Got Rhythm.”  The pop-music sommelier in me would pair “I’ve Got A Crush On You” with “Surfer Girl,” “I Got Plenty O’ Nothing” with “God Only Knows,” and “‘S Wonderful” with “Kokomo.”  A complete stream of the album is available (for now).

What interests me most, of course, is the use of Rhapsody in Blue. The piece appears as the opening and closing tracks of the album (Rhapsody in Blue/Intro and Reprise).  Between these official bookends, however, the Rhapsody emerges creatively, revealing the overarching influence of the piece not only on this particular album, but on Wilson’s own musical makeup as a whole.

Wilson has spoken affectionately of Rhapsody in Blue: “I was 2 years old when I experienced the first taste of Gershwin magic. My mother was playing ‘Rhapsody in Blue’ — the Leonard Bernstein version — and all I could think was how it was the most beautiful thing in the world.”  It probably was not Bernstein’s version that he heard at age 2 (or 4 depending on the interview) since it was not recorded until 1959, when Wilson was seventeen.  Regardless, for Wilson the Rhapsody, “was everything.  The chords, the melodic movement, the arranging, the impetus, the excitement, the beauty. It was just an absolute work of art.”  It seems particularly apt that Wilson should admire the various musical aspects of the Rhapsody that he does, especially that of arrangement.  Albums such as Pet Sounds and Smile unite a series of individual songs into carefully designed extended compositions in their own right.  The same might be said of Rhapsody in Blue.

The opening and closing tracks don’t feature the entire Rhapsody, but rather a rendition of the soaring andantino “love” theme.  Wilson “reimagines” this famous melody as a series of stacked, block-chord harmonies.  Overdubbed to create five-part harmony, this style is easily recognizable as the Beach Boys.  The “love” theme’s counter-melody, played here by woodwinds, recalls the lead vocal line of songs such as “I Get Around,” lending both coherence and momentum to the sustained harmonies of the backup vocals.**

In Gershwin’s original Rhapsody in Blue the “love” theme finds no resolution: it develops into an extended piano cadenza never to be heard in full again.  Although Wilson’s version concludes with a neat and tidy cadence, over the course of the next twelve tracks on the album, the Rhapsody is treated to its own sort of development. In several instances–some obvious, some more subtle–Wilson incorporates themes from the Rhapsody into his “reimaginations” of other songs.

“I Got Rhythm” begins with four measures of the “stride” theme played by a saxophone and electric guitar.  There is an ascending half-step motive that is heard three times in this theme, which is picked up by the guitar and turned into a surf-style vamp.

“Someone to Watch Over Me” begins with an “Eleanor Rigby”-esque string quartet playing a modulating “shuffle” theme.  The electric bass segue between this and the entrance of the refrain riffs on the theme, expanding the intervals but following its general rhythm and arc.

“I Got Plenty of Nuttin'” concludes with a cello solo based on the “tag” theme.”

The bridge of “Nothing But Love,” the second of the “new” songs on the album**, introduces another multi-voiced reworking of the “love” theme.  Instead of block-chords, however, Wilson retrofits it with another familiar Beach Boys vocal technique: polyphonic layering.

“Nothing But Love” ends with another instance of the “stride” theme, this time played on cello, which leads directly into the Rhapsody in Blue/Reprise.  The reprise, like its introductory counterpart, offers a very satisfying final cadence.

Although there are some moments I find a bit trying (Was “I Loves You Porgy” really necessary?), on the whole I find album catchy, engaging, and delightfully well arranged.  It captures Wilson’s long-standing admiration for Gershwin.  In an NPR interview with On Point host Tom Ashbrook, Wilson declared:  “It was universally accepted that [Gershwin] was the greatest musical originator in the history of music.”  Although I don’t disagree, there are some that would say Wilson oversteps here.  There are others who would say the same about Wilson.  I don’t think I’d disagree with that either.  In either case, Brian Wilson Reimagines Gershwin presents the music of both innovators in a new light and to a new generation.


* Yes, I know that it wasn’t actually a Theremin used in the song “Good Vibrations.”

** This setting also reminds me of Leonard Bernstein’s nineteen-year-old reimagination of the Rhapsody for a group of summer camp performers, which also vocalizes this theme–though I doubt highly that Brian Wilson would have been aware of this!

*** There are two “new” songs on this album.  the Gershwin estate given Wilson his pick of 100+ unfinished songs with the hope that he might finish a few of them.  Another post for another day…

Share on Facebook

Entry filed under: Review, Ryan Raul Bañagale. Tags: , , , , , .

Guest Post by Matthew Mugmon: Learning to decipher archival documents, one letter (or number) at a time Back To School Musicology Blog Reading


  • 1. Ralph Locke  |  August 24, 2010 at 2:48 pm

    Fascinating, and great to have the sound-clips, which make vividly clear the points you’ve laid out.

    Thanks for sharing all of this!

  • 2. John Hausmann  |  August 25, 2010 at 9:39 am

    Good post! I’ve heard as much of the tracks as iTunes will let me, which wasn’t enough to catch the different uses of the “Rhapsody.” That’s something that definitely warrants a closer listen.

    It’s also nice to read something more critically written than the iTunes reviews, some of which are enough to make you lose your faith in humanity.

  • 3. Ryan Raul Bañagale  |  August 27, 2010 at 7:24 am

    Thanks, John and Ralph. I find the album fascinating and the tunes have continued to rattle around my brain despite the fact that I haven’t listened to the CD all week. Behold the power of pop music.

    I’d like to pose a question based on a comment that came to me off-line:

    Are the various “Brian Wilson” techniques applied to the songs on this album enough to make up for the fact that the Gershwin’s rich harmonies are flattened out as a result? That is, has enough been added to balance out what has been taken away?

  • 4. WorkingMusician  |  September 5, 2010 at 10:11 am

    Wow… simply… wow. As a kid I was turned on to the Beach Boys and the brilliance of Brian Wilson. I’ve always loved his music, but the fusion of the Gershwin classics along with Brian Wilson’s unique approaches to composition make me want to get this album – now.

    Thanks for sharing this, I might have missed it otherwise!

  • 5. David  |  November 22, 2010 at 5:23 am

    Nice analysis. I’ve been more obsessed with Brian Wilson’s composition style than perhaps any other popular artist, and there is definitely enough on this album to be thrilled with, even if it doesn’t always work. It is a real joy to hear those Beach Boys style harmonies and rhythms in the kind of clarity that was missing from his early 60s’ mono recordings (good as they are). I find nowadays that Wilson is more given to overproducing some of his material, and does let himself down with occasional saccharine undertones, but that’s just nitpicking given it’s amazing the guy is still kicking around. To hear “You Can’t Take Away from Me”, “I Got Rhythm” and “Nothing But Love” – you can’t help but be transported back to that time the Beach Boys first weaved their spell on you.


Amusicology is an online forum for musicologists, academic or otherwise. Although Ryan Raul Banagale and Drew Massey are its founders and chief contributors, we welcome guest submissions. Please let us know if you would like to contribute a guest posting. Comments are always welcome and encouraged!

Please bookmark us or add our RSS feed.

Bookmark and Share

Twitter: Amusicology in 140 Characters or Less!

  • RT @anthonyocampo: Anti-Asian racism isn’t un-American—it’s quintessentially American. You can’t kill millions of Asians across the Pacific… Posted by Ryan 10 months ago
  • For the record, on this first day of distance learning: teaching college is way Way WAY easier than teaching elemen…… Posted by Ryan 1 year ago


%d bloggers like this: